Warhammer is an expensive hobby, but if you know where to look, you can build massive armies, pick up rare books, and even score entire collections for next to nothing. Over the years, I’ve put together huge Warhammer Fantasy and 40K collections, snagged HeroQuest, Warhammer Quest, and Necromunda sets, and tracked down classic Rogue Trader-era models—all without paying eBay prices.
The trick is knowing where to look, how to negotiate, and when to take a chance on a deal. Most of my biggest finds have come from Craigslist, estate sales, local marketplaces, and online auctions, using a few strategies I picked up while hunting for rare paintball markers like Automags and Autocockers. If you’re patient, persistent, and willing to put in the work, there are incredible deals out there.

Now that I’m no longer living in the USA, I figure it’s time to share all my personal secrets—since I can’t use them anymore!
The Greatest Deal I Ever Scored: 6 Armies for $180
My best second-hand Warhammer deal of all time happened in Maryland, where I picked up six full armies for just $180 cash. It was an absolute steal, but there was a catch:
- I couldn’t resell anything—the seller wanted it to go to a good home, not an eBay flipper.
- I had to pay it forward—the idea was to use it to grow my local gaming group rather than hoarding it all for myself.
It was a deal based on trust, but it paid off. I ended up using those armies to help new players get into the hobby, which is something I still try to do whenever I can. Deals like this don’t happen every day, but if you network and build a reputation, you’ll eventually find people willing to offload their collections at a fraction of their value—especially if they know it’s going to a good home.



The Empire Army That Flew Across the Country
One of my more memorable Craigslist finds was a massive Warhammer Fantasy Empire army, which showed up in an ad from Arizona. Normally, distance would have made this a non-starter, but by sheer luck, the seller regularly flew to Northern Virginia for work.
We coordinated over email, and I ended up meeting him minutes from my house to buy his entire collection over the course of two of his business trips. The whole deal went down in a fast-food joint in a strip mall right before he had to return to work. One of his coworkers, who came along for lunch, was pretty amused watching us conduct the transaction—swapping cash for boxes of meticulously packed miniatures.
Craigslist is full of opportunities like this, and you never know when a deal will line up perfectly if you’re patient.
Craigslist and SearchTempest: Finding Warhammer in Forgotten Places
Craigslist is one of the best places to find second-hand Warhammer, but its search function is terrible—you can only look in one city at a time. That’s where SearchTempest comes in. It lets you search all Craigslist listings across the USA, Mexico, and Canada at once, making it much easier to find deals.

The best deals tend to show up in places where Warhammer isn’t as popular. Smaller towns and rural areas often have old collections sitting in basements, and since there’s less local demand, sellers tend to price things cheaper. I’ve found entire armies this way, along with books like Realms of Chaos and Rogue Trader that would normally go for a fortune online. I once picked up a bunch of 1980s era citadel orc war machine and dwarf lords boxes from a second hand store in a small town this way listed as “toys”.
If you find something interesting, reach out to the seller as soon as possible. Craigslist isn’t designed for shipping, so you’ll need to convince the seller to mail it to you. Many won’t ship at all, and others are worried about scams, so you’ll often have to pay first and take a risk. Offering extra for their time and hassle can help.
Set Alerts for Free Warhammer
One of the best tricks for getting Warhammer for free is setting up alerts for $0 price listings and curb alerts on Craigslist.
People clearing out their garages will sometimes list Warhammer models for free or leave them on the curb for anyone to take. This isn’t common, but when it happens, it’s worth the effort. I once picked up an entire Tau army off the side of the road in Virginia—Crisis Suits, Fire Warriors, and even a Hammerhead tank. Someone was literally throwing them away.
To do this, search for “Warhammer,” “Games Workshop,” “40K,” and similar terms, then set the price range to $0. If you see something, move fast—free listings don’t last long.
Check Local Marketplaces When Traveling
One of my favorite tricks is checking local buy/sell marketplaces when I’m traveling, both in the USA and overseas. Every country and region has its version of Craigslist or Facebook Marketplace, and Warhammer prices can vary wildly depending on the area.
If you plan to do this, keep in mind:
- You’ll usually need a rental car to pick up larger lots.
- Make sure you have space in your luggage if you plan to bring models back.
- Some sellers are more open to bulk discounts, especially if they’re clearing out a collection.
I’ve found incredible deals this way by taking a few minutes to check local marketplaces before arriving in a new area. You never know when someone’s clearing out a Warhammer stash that’s been gathering dust for years.



Avoiding Scams and Staying Safe
Most people selling Warhammer second-hand are just looking to clear out old hobby stuff, but you should still be careful.
- For local pickups, meet in a public place—never go to someone’s house alone.
- Tell someone where you’re going before meeting a seller.
- If a deal feels sketchy, bail.
So far, I haven’t woken up in a bathtub full of ice missing my kidneys… yet.
That said, be smart about it. Warhammer is expensive, but it’s not that expensive.

Final Thoughts
If you want to build a massive Warhammer collection without breaking the bank, second-hand markets are the way to go. Craigslist, estate sales, and online auctions all have incredible deals if you’re willing to put in the effort.
- Use Craigslist + SearchTempest to scan multiple locations.
- Set up alerts for $0 price listings and curb alerts—sometimes you’ll get models for free.
- Check estate sales and online auctions like HiBid for forgotten collections (some of my best scores were on here).
- Look beyond Craigslist to Facebook Marketplace and OfferUp.
- Check local marketplaces when traveling—Warhammer prices vary by region.
- Negotiate with sellers—many have more than what they listed.
- Stay safe and don’t take unnecessary risks.
I’ve been doing this since I was a kid in New Zealand, when I bought my first second-hand copy of Warhammer 40K 2nd Edition from a classified ad in Trade & Exchange. If you’re patient and persistent, there are still incredible deals out there.
If you’ve scored an amazing second-hand Warhammer deal, drop a comment and let me know!
























































































